Two Decades of Quality Deck Building

Firepit vs. Fireplace: 8 Factors to Keep in Mind

Home > Outdoor Living > Firepit vs. Fireplace: 8 Factors to Keep in Mind

Firepit vs. Fireplace: 8 Factors to Keep in Mind

Firepit vs Fireplace

If you’re thinking about getting a firepit vs. fireplace, it’s easy to get stuck wondering what the best choice would be. Depending on your lifestyle and personal preferences, one option might appeal to you more than the other, but it can be hard to know which one that would be until you try it out. 

Luckily, no matter which option you choose, certain factors will improve the experience, even if your decision eventually turns out to have been the wrong one. Check out these key factors to help make your decision between a fire pit and a fireplace that much easier.

Firepit vs. Fireplace: What’s the Difference? 

A fire pit is a bowl or pit-shaped structure used to contain fires. It’s often made of metal, stone, or brick and is mainly used for bonfires. Fire pits are a great way to enjoy the outdoors with friends and family. Outdoor concrete fire pits require low maintenance and will increase your property’s value.

A fireplace is a permanent wall structure made of brick, stone, or metal designed to contain a fire. The inside is lined with non-combustible materials such as clay bricks and mortar and often has steel mesh screens called firebricks on the front. They are versatile and are a perfect fit both indoors and outdoors. 

There’s nothing like relaxing in front of a roaring fireplace on a cold winter night. The warmth they provide, the ambiance they create, and their attractive design are why many homeowners consider them a great addition to their new deck.

But before you decide which to install on your new deck, house, or outdoors, below are some factors to consider:

1. Available Space

One of the main factors you’ll want to consider when deciding between a firepit and a fireplace is the amount of space you have. For example, a firepit might be the way to go if you have a large backyard. But a fireplace might be a better option if you have a smaller patio or deck.

2. Cost of Installation 

Compare your budget with the cost of installation and maintenance. Although both options are relatively inexpensive, fireplaces tend to be more expensive to install than firepits. 

This is because fireplaces require more materials and typically need to be built into the structure of your home. On the other hand, firepits can be placed on top of various surfaces and are usually less expensive to install.

3. Aesthetics

Fireplace with a woman

Nobody wants a structure that isn’t aesthetically pleasing anywhere on their property. Generally, a fireplace tends to be more polished and refined, while a firepit can be more rustic and relaxed. 

If you’re trying to decide which would look better with your new deck, take time to research both options and weigh out what’s best for you.

4. Safety 

Safety should always be your top priority when it comes to outdoor fires. How close to trees or other flammable objects is your deck? 

How high is your new deck’s roof line? (Firepits can’t go over two feet tall). In addition, consider the number of people that will be on the deck at any given time. 

Finally, keep in mind that fireplaces have glass doors that will provide more protection from wind gusts than firepits do.

5. Capacity 

How many people do you want to be able to accommodate? A firepit can typically seat more people than a fireplace, making it an excellent option for large gatherings. However, a fireplace might be the way to go if you’re looking for a more intimate setting.

6. Heat Output

How much heat do you need? Both will provide warmth, but fireplaces tend to put out more heat. So a firepit might be enough if you’re looking to take the chill off on a cool evening. But a fireplace is probably your best bet if you’re looking to cozy up on a cold night.

7. Weather and the Environment

firepit vs. fireplace: Firepit overlooking forest

Another factor to consider when deciding between a firepit and a fireplace is the environment. For example, if you live in an area with high winds, a firepit might not be the best option since it’s more exposed. Additionally, a fireplace is better suited for a backyard with many trees around it or any moisture from rain or snow.

8. HOA Restriction Recommendations 

If you live in a neighborhood with a homeowners’ association, you’ll also want to factor that into your decision. Some HOAs have strict rules about what kinds of outdoor fire features are allowed, and you don’t want to get hit with a fine or have to tear out your brand new firepit because it doesn’t meet the HOA’s guidelines. It’s always best to check before installing. 

There are also differences between some homeowners’ associations and condos regarding these regulations. For example, condos may not allow fires on balconies. Still, the association might allow them on patios so long as they’re at least 10 feet away from other buildings.

Final Thoughts

Factor comparison is not necessary when deciding between firepits vs. fireplaces because both options have different benefits depending on what you want from the space. 

At Dupont Decks, we want you to make an informed decision that will be best for your specific needs. Besides building your new deck, we have a fantastic variety of fireplaces that you’ll wish every room had. Contact us to help you live your best life and enhance your home, even on the outside.



DON’T Miss out!

Join our mailing list and be the first to recieve updates, exclusive content, and more!